There are no asset bubbles

Posted by Ray on November 16, 2009 under Main | Be the First to Comment

According to Ben and now his number 2, Donald Kohn, there are no more asset bubbles in the US, none at all. This is coming from the same Fed that missed the mother of all housing bubbles and continually either lied to themselves or us to the severity of the bubble, when they realized it was busting, after the fact. These are not exactly what I would refer to as credible words of comfort when they messed up so badly to begin with.

However, considering we lost millions of jobs in the last 6 months alone and had horrible economic data all while the stock market climbed an unprecedented 60% from its lows, a feat that usually takes 2 years after a recovery has actually occurred, there is no bubble. Right. In my opinion we went from one horrific bubble, what was the mother of all bubbles, to the greatest ,biggest, most fantastic bubble of all time created by the Fed on purpose. I realize that everyone thinks everything is fine now that the market is up and we had a wonderful 3Q09 GDP figure, which will be revised down to 2.5-3%, that was 110% stimulus induced, and do not fool yourself and think it was not, but things are ugly.

We are still reporting 500K initial claims a week, last month if you look at the official number we actually lost some 276K jobs, the BLS added some 86K via the birth/death model, and unemployment is at 11%+. That’s right, I said unemployment is at 11%+ right now and I can prove it. According to the BLS they understated employment by some 800K in the beginning of this year, this was announced in September 2009 by the BLS, which means we are not counting some 800K people who are unemployed because the BLS fudges the numbers with the birth/death model, go look to see their actual numbers they add in HERE.

My point is that there has never been a point in history where the market climbed 60% from its lows in a mere 6 months while we are still shedding jobs. Given that employment has been overstated, or understated depending on how you look at it, and we have had weak or anemic, albeit better, economic data this equity move is unparalleled and is the basic definition of an asset bubble. Here are 2 other things that should make you say hmm, treasuries are doing very well, still, which is highly unusual in a economic recovery, come on stocks and treasuries can’t both be right, and precious metals are also going through the roof.

It is impossible to have every or virtually every asset class go up and have them all be right. According to the markets, which are horrible future forecasters, see September 2007 Dow 14,000 for proof, we are facing deflation or a continued recession with treasuries going up, inflation with commodities doing very well or a complete economic recovery with stocks and corporate bonds going through the roof. Do you see my point? They cannot all be right, it is not possible. I know I will get hate mail for this next statement, but here it goes, stocks are stupid money and that is a fact. Credit markets and the FX markets are always where the smart money is, hence the reason why those markets dwarf the equity markets. If you think about it you know I am right, stocks are last in line during bankruptcy!

The point I am making is this, equities are for gamblers, like me and probably you. The credit markets represent the smartest of the smartest money and what is that market telling you? Treasuries are saying there are still major problems out there, as they are going up, and corporate bonds are pricing in 2% GDP growth. Stocks, however, are pricing in some 4%+ GDP growth with job creation and even credit expansion, none of which is actually happening in real life. I can talk until I am blue in the face about valuation and such, but it will do absolutely no good because people do what people do, they see stocks go up and jump on at the very end to ride them all the way down.

In fact CNBC stated today that the retail investor is coming into the market now. Why? Because human behavior is predictable. They wait for things to go up and then see their friends buying stocks, making money and feel left out and jump on the bandwagon. I saw this happen in 1999/2000 only to see people get killed when the market corrected, which it will, because when we see the behavior I am talking about it is the sign of an asset bubble. It is what happened during every bubble we have had and then we will look back in a year and say how were these people so dumb to fall for it? For the record, I do not think all people are dumb I just think people make bad decisions based on faulty advice and herd mentality.

I also do not think retail investors are jumping into this market as net flows do not show that type of activity, equities still show net redemptions not in flows, so CNBC is flat out wrong. Oh, there is also no money on the sidelines so just forget about that argument it does not exist. That money is sitting in money market accounts because people want it liquid and/or it is part of an asset allocation. In fact, that money has not moved off the sidelines in 15 years so I highly doubt it will move now. If it did, which it is not, that is further evidence of a bubble driven by cheap money as the Fed is literally forcing people to risk their principle to make any return.

The Fed can say all they want that there is no bubble because you and I know there is a major bubble out there. Well, you should know that unless you think 60% rallies happen all the time in a mature market and economy. I think what the Fed is saying is that there is no bubble in securitization or in the housing market, which is debatable, but there is one heck of a bubble in stocks. The one thing I do know for sure is that all bubbles pop, I just do not know when, but this one will go soon and it will be spectacular.