The employment report will be bad, worse than you think
Posted by Ray on July 1, 2010 under Economy, Markets | 
Be the First to Comment
Everyone is expecting a bad employment report, especially after the ADP report on Wednesday and the initial claims data this morning, but I think it will be worse than most people believe. Estimates are for modest private payroll growth, meaning poor of course, but given the weak data that came in waves this month it is bound to be less robust than we think. I am one of the few who believe there is a very strong possibility of private payroll losses tomorrow, not merely a weak report, but a disastrous report. I am not referring to the census workers being laid off either.
I expect huge losses in construction jobs which will offset any manufacturing gains we have. The housing, initial claims and extended jobless benefit data points are what lead me to believe that we will see a train wreck tomorrow. It is clear that the economic indicators are rolling over, from the ISM to the ECRI all the way to housing, which should not shock anyone. What most people fail to realize, but not economists, is that housing represents some 20% of GDP and the data we saw is telling us that the construction industry must have been shedding jobs, in the residential market, like crazy. This is also why the home buyer tax credit is going to get extended as well, of, and it is also an election year.
Overall, I do not believe a bad employment report is priced into the market and that is certainly not good news for the bulls. I am also curious to see what the birth/death model adjustment is going to add to the mix, while many in bobble head says the B/D adjustment is not a big deal, well, they are wrong. As I have said many times, the B/D model underestimated unemployment by 880,000 jobs last year, that is a big deal so these adjustments do matter, sorry Mr. Liesman. I also believe we will see wages stagnate with the work week getting slightly longer, why hire more people when you can have existing employees work more hours? It is unclear whether or not the unemployment rate will increase, I suspect it will, because the unemployment benefits were not extended by the Senate leaving 1.7M unemployed without a check. In other words, 1.7M people might have all of a sudden decided to look for a job, any job, which will increase the unemployment rate. The rest of the report will reflect what we know, it will merely confirm it for us.
The $60,000 question is whether a really bad employment report is priced into the market or not. I am inclined to believe that nothing is really ever priced in especially if the report is worse than expected. The market is due for a bounce and I actually thought we would get it today, it looked like we were at some points throughout the afternoon, but it did not happen. The market is definitely oversold, but markets can remain oversold or overbought for long periods of time, heck we were overbought for how long and no one complained. The market is in bad shape from a technical perspective and there are enormous headwinds in front of us from a weakening economy to the troubles in Europe. The one thing I am confident about is my 900 price target for the S&P is intact and we are well on the way to that level or lower. One hedge fund manager I spoke to has a Dow target of 3,800 and thinks we will reach new lows on the S&P 500 so next to him I am a raging bull.
If the report is bad it is possible we will trade higher to retest that 1040 – 1048 level which would be an ideal level to consider looking at short positions, depending on conditions at that point and your investment objectives, there are never any sure things. The other unknown about tomorrow is the 3 day weekend that is in front of us. I am fairly confident few will want to be short into the long weekend, but I am equally as confident that few will want to be long either. Many traders may not be around which could mean a low volume indecisive day altogether. However, if I am right and it the report is a negative number I am fairly confident we trade lower, but this market is full of surprises, both up and down.
There is one item that makes me a bit more bearish than usual and that is the way AAPL has been trading. I realize it has been plagued with some rumors or truths, I do not own Apple products, happily, so I do not know what is true or not true, but it certainly has not been able to catch a break lately. This was supposed to be the ‘safe’ stock with $50 per share in cash and THE product to own and it has fallen sharply off of its highs. Everyone loves AAPL and everyone owns AAPL, I am using AAPL as most used GS at the beginning of the year, as the canary in the coal mine. What AAPL is saying is there is a gas leak as the stock has fallen 30 points from its all-time high and it cannot shake off bad news. The weakness in stocks like AAPL are telling me that investors are treading lightly in risk assets, not to mention that they were overvalued, oh the emails I will get for that comment.
The bottom line is that even if I am wrong and the employment report is ‘good’ with a +150K private employment print, unlikely in my opinion, it really isn’t good news, just less bad. With unemployment officially at about 10% and underemployment pushing 16% we have a real structural employment problem in America. It is so bad that Vice President Biden admitted that many of the 8M jobs lost will never come back, this is the same guy who said we would be swimming in hundreds of thousands of jobs every month ‘very soon’ a couple of months ago. This is deflationary and the fact that wages are basically stagnant is deflationary. The credit markets are telling us that deflation is the immediate risk at this point. Retail sales show that there is no end demand, running at a mere 1%, all of this mixed with high unemployment is if not actual deflation disinflation which is very bearish for stocks. We will continue to have a P/E multiple compressions because of this disinflationary force and earnings estimates will come down, a lot. In short, even if we have a good day tomorrow, unless we see some real inflation equity prices are heading lower.
Subscribe to Annuity IQ's FeedLS Blogs
